The world of ecommerce is highly competitive, so you need to find ways to stand out and increase sales.

One powerful psychological tactic that can help you achieve this is The Decoy Effect. By understanding and leveraging this effect, you can nudge your customers towards making purchasing decisions that benefit your business. In today’s issue, we check out the psychology behind the decoy effect and how you can apply it in your ecommerce strategy.

Understanding the Decoy Effect

The decoy effect is a cognitive bias that occurs when a less appealing option is introduced to make one of the other options seem more attractive. This can influence consumer decision-making and lead your visitors to choose a specific option that they may not have considered otherwise. The decoy effect works by manipulating the perceived value of the options, making one option appear superior in comparison to the others.

To illustrate this effect, Let's take a look at how Apple applies this in its iPad line-up.

Imagine you're considering the standard 10th Gen iPad, priced at $449.

It's a solid tablet, but the screen and A14 Bionic chip are nothing special by today's standards. So, you’ll look at the iPad Air for $599, because it has a better screen and faster M1 Chip.

🔍 But then you notice - for just $200 more - the iPad Pro. It tempts you with a even better screen and the latest M2 Chipc Island cutout, although it does mean that the size of the screen is still relatively small.

And finally, you land on the iPad Pro with a 12.9: display at $1099. At this price it presents no compromises.

What started as a budget of $449 has now become $1099.

It's a classic case of the Decoy Effect in action

The Science Behind the Decoy Effect

The decoy effect was first described in a 1981 academic paper by Joel Huber, John Payne, and Christopher Puto. In their experiments, participants were presented with scenarios involving various products and asked to make choices. The introduction of the decoy option consistently influenced participants' decision-making, leading them to choose the target option over the competitor.

The decoy effect works by exploiting our cognitive biases and decision-making shortcuts. When faced with a multitude of options, consumers often experience choice overload. This can lead to decision-making paralysis and anxiety. To simplify the decision-making process, consumers tend to focus on a few key criteria, such as price and quantity, to determine the best value for money.

By manipulating these key choice attributes, the decoy steers consumers towards a particular option while giving them the illusion of making a rational and informed choice. This effect is a form of "nudging," a concept introduced by Richard Thaler and Cass Sunstein in their book "Nudge”. Nudging refers to any aspect that alters people's behavior in a predictable way.

Applying the Decoy Effect in Ecommerce

So how do you apply this hack in your ecommerce strategy?

Here are some practical tips:

1. Understand Your Customers' Decision-Making Process

To effectively leverage the decoy effect, you need to have a deep understanding of your customers' decision-making process. You need to do market research, analyze customer data, and gather insights to identify the key criteria that influence your customers’ purchasing decisions. This will help you determine which attributes to manipulate and which options to present as decoys.

2. Identify Key Choice Attributes

Once you have a clear understanding of your customers' decision-making process, identify the key choice attributes that are most important to them. These attributes can vary depending on your industry and product offerings. Common attributes are price, features, quality, quantity, and convenience. By focusing on these attributes, you can create decoy options that highlight the superiority of your target option.

3. Create a Compelling Target Option

Your target option should be the one you want your customers to choose. It should offer a clear advantage over the other options, making it the most appealing choice. Highlight the unique value proposition of your target option and emphasize the benefits that set it apart from the competition. By creating a compelling target option, you increase the chance of customers choosing it over the other alternatives.

4. Introduce a Decoy Option

The decoy option should be strategically designed to make the target option more attractive. It should be inferior in some aspects but still offer some value to the customer. The goal is to make the target option seem like a better value for money compared to the decoy. Experiment with different pricing, features, or package options to find the most effective decoy for your target option.

5. Present Options Side by Side

When presenting the options to your customers, make sure they are displayed side by side for easy comparison. This visual representation allows customers to evaluate the attributes and make a more informed decision. Highlight the key differences between the options and clearly demonstrate the superiority of your target option. Use clear and concise language to convey the value proposition of each option.

6. Use Social Proof and Reviews

Incorporate social proof and customer reviews into your product pages to enhance the perceived value of your target option. Positive reviews and testimonials from happy customers can reinforce the superiority of your option and increase trust in your brand. Highlight the benefits and positive experiences of previous customers to influence potential buyers' decision-making.

7. Offer Limited-Time Deals

Create a sense of urgency and scarcity by offering limited-time deals or promotions for your target option. This can create a fear of missing out (FOMO) and encourage customers to make a decision quickly. By highlighting the exclusive nature of the deal, you can make your target option even more appealing compared to the decoy and other alternatives.

8. Track and Analyze Results

As with any marketing strategy, it is essential to track and analyze the results of your decoy effect implementation. Monitor sales, conversion rates, and customer feedback to assess the effectiveness of your strategy. Experiment with different variations of the decoy and target options to optimize your approach based on real-time data and customer insights.

9. Continuously Refine Your Strategy

Ecommerce is constantly evolving, and consumer preferences may change over time. Keep optimizing your decoy effect strategy based on market trends, customer feedback, and competitor analysis. Stay updated with the latest research and insights on consumer psychology to ensure your approach remains effective and relevant.

TL:DR

Understanding the psychology behind the decoy effect is a powerful tool for any ecommerce business. By strategically applying this effect in your ecommerce strategy, you can influence customer decision-making and increase sales. Remember to always prioritize the needs and preferences of your customers, providing them with valuable options and exceptional experiences. With a deep understanding of your target audience and careful implementation, the decoy effect can be a game-changer in your ecommerce success.

Have a great Sunday!
Erik

Whenever you’re ready, there are a three ways I can help you:

1. Download the E-Commerce Audit Report. A +300 items checklist that identifies areas of improvement of your e-commerce store.

2. Book a 1:1 Call. A No Bullshit 30 min Ask Me Anything call. If you’re facing challenges in online business, I’m happy to share my decade of experience.

3. Midjourney Masterclass. A self paced course on how to use Midjourney to create impressive visual content, efficiently.